Tuesday, December 31, 2013

Minutes of the Personnel/HR Committee meeting 12/5/13



MINUTES
FOR THE PERSONNEL/HUMAN RESOURCES COMMITTEE
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
IRONHOUSE SANITARY DISTRICT

DATE:      December 5, 2013
TIME:       Meeting start time 2:00 p.m.
PLACE:     Ironhouse Sanitary District Office
450 Walnut Meadows Drive
Oakley, Ca. 94561
ATTENDANCE:  David Huerta, David Contreras, Tom Williams


A.      Roll Call.  All present

B.       Approval of the Agenda.  M/S David Contreras, David Huerta

C.       Public Comments.  No public comment

D.      Approval of meeting minutes of November 1, 2013 for the Personnel/Human Resources Committee Meeting.  M/S David Contreras, David Huerta and the draft meeting minutes were approved as submitted.

E.       Discussion with General Manager and Water Recycling Facility Managers regarding the need for a permanent Electrician/Instrumentation Technician.  A PowerPoint presentation was presented to the Committee by management staff (Joe Mueller and Marc Haefke). The presentation addressed the position need, utilization, cost, and recruitment.  In addition, staff estimated the costs if outside consultants were utilized to perform the 1500 hours of recurring operating and maintenance activities, vs. the estimated savings of using an in-house permanent staff member to perform the same tasks.  Lastly, staff went over additional benefits/utilization of the Electrical/Instrumentation Technician, and how over time the District may be able to somewhat reduce its cost and reliance on outside consultants.

The committee reviewed the information and asked questions. The committee also requested staff return at the next meeting with greater detail related to previous utilization of outside consultants, the work performed, hours spent, breakdown of costs, and invoices.  Staff wanted to make clear the outside consultants, and the costs associated with their work, have been for needed repair work, and not the recurring O & M work staff needs to perform year-round.  So, the information the Committee is looking for from staff only validates the average consultant costs per hour.  Then, the consultant cost per hour can be used to perform a cost savings analysis of consultant vs. permanent ISD staff in performing the necessary recurring O & M work.  The committee understood.  
F.       Discussion of future items for the Personnel/Human Resources Committee and proposed meeting dates.  The Committee asked to discuss Succession Planning at a committee meeting in the near future.  In an effort to place the proposed position on the January 2014 Board agenda; the next meeting was scheduled for December 19, 2013 at 9:00a.m.

I.        Adjournment.  The meeting adjourned at 4:15 p.m.

Minutes of the Personnel/HR Committee meeting 12/19/13




MINUTES
FOR THE PERSONNEL/HUMAN RESOURCES COMMITTEE
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
IRONHOUSE SANITARY DISTRICT

DATE:      December 19, 2013
TIME:       Meeting start time 9:25 a.m.
PLACE:     Ironhouse Sanitary District Office
450 Walnut Meadows Drive
Oakley, Ca. 94561
ATTENDANCE:  David Huerta, David Contreras, Tom Williams


A.      Roll Call.  All present

B.       Approval of the Agenda.  M/S David Contreras, David Huerta

C.       Public Comments.  No public comment

D.      Approval of meeting minutes of December 5, 2013 for the Personnel/Human Resources Committee Meeting.  Due to a technical error, the correct meeting minutes were unavailable and no action was taken.  Staff indicated the meeting minutes for the December 5th & 19th, meetings will be presented for approval at the next meeting. 

E.       Discussion with General Manager regarding the need for a permanent Electrical/Instrumentation Technician and Committee recommendation to the Board.  Mr. Tom Williams presented the Committee with the Electrical/Instrumentation Technician follow-up information (prepared by Mr. Joe Mueller) requested at the previous meeting.  Mr. Williams discussed the information and how Mr. Mueller determined average per hour consultant costs, cost anticipated if consultants did all the 1500 hours of recurring O & M activities, as well as cost savings if permanent in-house staff performed the recurring O & M activities.  The Committee understood the information but requested further submittal of consultant costs and activities in spreadsheet format.  The Committee requested at the next meeting they see a breakdown of the Electrical and Programming consultants used over the last year, the projects each worked on, the hours for each job, the project costs, the cost per hour, and the overall average cost per hour.  The Committee felt this information will help make clear, and validate, the average per hour consultant cost used in the analysis, as well as assist the Committee and the Board in better understanding the need for creating a permanent position in-house.
Mr. Williams wanted to make clear the outside consultants, and the costs associated with their work, have been for needed repair work, and not the 1500 hours of recurring O & M work staff needs to perform year-round.  So, the information the Committee is looking for from staff only validates the average consultant costs per hour.  Then, the consultant cost per hour can be used to perform a cost savings analysis of consultant vs. permanent ISD staff in performing the necessary recurring O & M work.  The committee understood.  
F.       Review and discuss CSDA’s “Organizational Health Assessment and Planner for Special Districts” publication.  The Committee reviewed and discussed the CSDA publication and, overall, the Committee liked the document.  The Committee asked Mr. Williams to thoroughly review the document and then distribute it, including the survey portion of the document, to staff and the Board for review and comment/feedback from all.  Once feedback is received, the Committee would like to go over the information with Mr. Williams and develop a plan for improving the organization based on the comments received.
G.      Discussion of future Items for the Personnel/Human Resources Committee and proposed meeting dates.  The next meeting was scheduled for Monday, December 30, 2013 at 9:00a.m.

H.      Adjournment.  The meeting adjourned at 11:45 a.m.

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Minutes of the November 5, 2013 Board Meeting




MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE
IRONHOUSE SANITARY DISTRICT

November 5, 2013

The Ironhouse Sanitary District (ISD) Board of Directors met in regular session on Tuesday, November 5, 2013.

The place of meeting was the Ironhouse Sanitary District Office at 450 Walnut Meadows Drive, Oakley, California. 

1.                Call to Order
The meeting was called to order by President Lauritzen at 7:00 p.m.

2.         Roll Call:
Directors present:                David Contreras, David Huerta, Chris Lauritzen, Michael Painter and Doug Scheer

          Members absent:                None

Staff/Consultants present:     Tom Williams, General Manager
Jennifer Skrel, District Engineer
                                                Susan Walde, District Secretary
                                                Fred Etzel, District Counsel
                                                Michael Welty, Financial Officer
                                                Joe Mueller, Environmental/Process Compliance Manager
                                               
          Interested Parties:               Susan Morgan, Oakley
                                                Justin Williams, Mann, Urrutia Nelson, CPAs and Associates, LLP

          Pledge of Allegiance:           Led by Tom Williams

          Employee Awards – Louis Solana – Mr. Solana was not able to attend and will accept award in December.

3.         Approval of Agenda
M/S M. Painter, D. Contreras, and the Board voted to approve the agenda.


4.         Approval of the Minutes of the October 1, 2013 Regular Meeting.
            Approval of the Minutes of the October 9, 2013 Special Meeting.
M/S D. Contreras, D. Huerta and the Board voted to approve the minutes of the October 1, 2013 Regular Meeting and the minutes of the October 9, 2013 special meeting with the following change to the minutes of October 9, 2013, Page 3 Director Painter “made” a recommendation.  President Lauritzen abstained from approval of the minutes of the October 1, 2013 meeting.
5.       Public Comments – Communications from the public on subjects not on the agenda. 
There were no comments from the public.


6.         Consent Calendar
            A.        Approval of Payment Order, Report on Financial Position & Operating Performance.
President Lauritzen asked about the prepaid connections.  Mr. Williams explained that there are multiple prepaid connections and as the properties are brought online they will show in the current year as revenue.

            B.        Consideration of 2014 District Holidays
            M/S M. Painter, D. Contreras and the Board voted to approve the consent calendar.


7.       Business Before the Board

7A.      CONSIDERATION OF PRELIMINARY FISCAL YEAR END JUNE 30, 2013 ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT WITH INDEPENDENT AUDITOR’S REPORT FROM MANN, URRUTIA, NELSON, CPAS & ASSOCIATES, LLP.
          Mr. Tom Williams introduced Justin Williams of Mann Urrutia Nelson, CPAs and Associates, LLP. Mr. J. Williams gave an overview of the audit process with ISD.  The process typically reviews controls, disbursements, payroll, and financial processes.  After ISD’s fiscal year closing, Mann Urrutia Nelson CPAs do  testing of selected areas of the District’s operations to prepare an audited financial statement.  He gave an unqualified opinion and reported that the audit was a clear audit with no audit adjustments. 
He reported that cash transfer reconciliation recommendations are already put in place and it is his recommendation staff update and adheres to the District’s bidding and procurement policies, last updated in 1995.  There were no material weaknesses and overall it was a very clean audit.  He thanked ISD staff for being so prepared.
M/S D. Huerta, D. Contreras and the Board voted to accept the audit as recommended by the Finance committee. 

          7B.   UPCOMING REVIEW AND RESPONSE TO PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT OF THE BDCP AND EIR/EIS.
          Mr. Fred Etzel reported that he, Director Contreras, and staff attended a workshop meeting on October 25th at CCWD regarding the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP).  Mr. Williams stated the State’s Bay Delta Conservation Plan is moving forward.  The formal public review period will run from December 13th to April 14th, 2014.  He is concerned with effects the BDCP may have on Jersey Island, ISD’s river discharge, salt intrusion, and RD 830.  Mr. Williams stated that the District has until April 2014 to submit a response letter to the California Department of Water Resources (DWR) and the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, collectively referred to as the Bay Delta Conservation Plan Proponents, commenting on the BDCP and its combined Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and Environmental Impact Statement (EIS).  Staff recommends the Board direct staff to prepare a comment letter for review by the Board at the March, 2014 meeting.
M/S D. Contreras, M. Painter and the Board voted unanimously to direct staff to prepare a draft response letter to the Draft BDCP and the EIR/EIS for review by the Board at the March 2014 meeting.

Mr. Williams stated he will be meeting with the Jersey Island Management Committee to prepare the response letter for ISD and Reclamation District 830 will also submit a response letter.


8.       Staff Reports
Joe Mueller – Mr. Mueller reported that on October 6, 2013 the Water Recycling Facility  started discharging to the river.  Mr. Mueller reported that he attended the Water Environment Federation annual conference in Chicago.  It was very informative and he was able to obtain vendor information, and information on screening improvements for future reference.  He reported that staff submitted responses on several procedural items; one on the UV reporting and one on QA/QC in response to the State inspection of the lab for certification.  

Jenny Skrel – Ms. Skrel reported that the Outfall to the river was inspected on Friday November 1st.  This is a requirement of the permit every two years.  The renewal of the NPDES permit is on the California Regional Water Quality Control Board agenda as a consent item for December 5-6, 2013.  She reported that staff is happy with the permit and the state addressed all the staff comments. 
Solar – The materials have started to arrive on site.  She reported she reviewed the switch gear and it has been ordered. Unfortunately, the switch gear is critical path, with delivery approximately 20 weeks from now.  Staff has been very timely in its response to contractor’s submittals, doing all we can to keep the project on-time.  The contractor will be moving his construction trailer on site soon and will begin installing the foundations in the near future.

Susan Walde – Mrs. Walde stated she submitted a written report.  She attended a workers compensation conference today with York insurance, our carrier, which was very informative. 

Tom Williams – Mr. Williams reported that two staff members will be retiring at the end of the year; Neil Sterud, Maintenance Supervisor and Beverly Dagneau, Sr. Account Technician.  Neil will be here until December 31st and Beverly’s last day is planned for November 26th.  Mr. Williams reported he met with the Personnel/Human Resources committee regarding backfilling the positions, and reported the committee concurred with  filling these positions internally.  Staff will be interviewing internally to fill Mr. Sterud’s position as Maintenance Supervisor and will ultimately hire a new person in the Maintenance Worker I/II position. 
Mr. Williams reported on the Bay Area Water & Wastewater Coalition meeting; he had Mr. Mueller attend the meeting to represent the District.  He reported that there was a representative from PG&E that spoke and reported there is a shortage of utility workers.  PG&E will be having a three month program for veterans for an opportunity to train for possible job placement.  The training will be  cover interviewing, job skills, and equipment handling.  At the end of the training, PG&E will host a job fair for all the trainees and will invite different agencies to participate.  This may be an opportunity for ISD in the future to hire well qualified individuals which are also veterans.  RD830 – The 8,000 foot stretch of levee work looks beautiful.  The shaping of the levees is excellent.  He reported RD830 has sent an advance request letter to DWR for the Marsh Creek project in the amount of $75,000.
He reported he has spent time working with staff and the auditor for the FY 12-13 audit.  He attended the CCSDA meeting on October 21st with Directors Scheer and Contreras.  Brent Ives was the speaker and spoke on succession planning. 
The ECWMA quarterly meeting will be held on November 14th at the ISD office. 11:30 will be meet and greet, 12:00 lunch and 12:30 business meeting.  Mr. Williams encourage the Board to take the opportunity to attend.
He reported that he will have the Strategic plan on the agenda for review at the December Board meeting. He proposed a possible workshop date of Thursday, November 21st at 2:00 for the Board to review the Strategic Plan.
Mr. Williams reported he attended the EC2 meeting at the Byron airport.  He gave a report on the program of the Patriot’s Jet Team Foundation, that are located at the airport and their volunteer program.  EC2  is working with businesses in the community to better understand the different opportunities available in East Contra Costa.  He reported on the proposed Route 239 connecting Tracy to Brentwood and the opportunities it would provide to local business.
BIMID will be hosting an all-day flood fighting training class on December 5th and both ISD and RD830 will be represented.


9.       Board Members Advisory Reports
Director Painter – Director Painter reported this Saturday, November 9, 2013, will be the opening day of Pheasant season.  He and Mr. Williams will be available on Jersey Island to facilitate hunters needing permits.  Pheasants Forever will meet at the District office on Thursday, November 7th at 7:00 p.m. to prepare for the opening of the season. 

He attended the Bay Delta Conference.  He reported on the panel of agencies represented.  He reported on the opinion of some that the Delta is broken and the different sections of the Delta have their problems.  It was a very informative conference. 

Doug Scheer – Director Scheer reported on attending Breakfast with the Mayor and concerns were brought up about  the delay with the Oakley power plant opening, which will also delay coming online with ISD. 

President Lauritzen – President Lauritzen reported on his recent trip, he was made aware of countries that don’ have ready access to clean water but have treatment processes.  How can we as a District utilize our high quality water for the benefit of the ratepayer? 

Director Contreras – Director Contreras reported that at the Bay Delta Conservation Plan workshop, both Mr. Williams and Ms. Skrel had an opportunity to talk with Contra Costa Water District about future opportunities to use our recycled water.
He also reported on the Outreach Committee- They are working P2Fog campaign for the upcoming holiday; advertising, signs, etc.  They are running two ads, one for after Thanksgiving and one for after Christmas.  The signs are going up for the event.  The committee has also worked to get the signs updated and in place on Jersey Island.  He also reported on the CCSDA meeting speaker Brent Ives.  Mr. Ives’ program was great, but he reported that succession planning is a key item for the organization, and one that we will encounter during the next five years.  The average age of the CEO in California is 53 years old.  Planning for retirement is important especially for key positions and it is the Board’s responsibility to guide the General Manager with clear direction. 
He also reported that Mrs. Gehlke is working with staff on updating the website, including mapping and stated it will look significantly different.  The Outreach committee is working on addressing all requirements needed for obtaining CSDA’s Transparency and District of Distinction accreditation and noted we are well on our way.


10.     Future Agenda Items for Consideration  
Recommendation on Accepting and Implementing the Total Compensation Study by Koff and Associates.
Annual Review of Strategic Plan


11.     Adjournment
President Lauritzen adjourned the regular meeting at 8:35 p.m. until Tuesday, December 3, 2013 at 7:00 p.m. for the next regular meeting in the Ironhouse Sanitary District offices at 450 Walnut Meadows Drive, Oakley, California.